The title of this post is comprised of the seven poorly-chosen words from a Vice President of Operations at a Detroit casino right before the casino terminated a white employee for allegedly botching supervision of a dealer card shuffle.
What do you think? Do we have a live race-discrimination claim? Oh yeah, we do! Details after the jump, as well as thoughts on employers who strive to maintain racial balance in the workplace...
Kimberly Ondricko, a white female, worked her way up through the ranks of the MGM Grand Detroit over several years from Casino Dealer-Trainee to Floor Supervisor. As a Floor Supervisor, her job, among other things, was to make sure the dealers that she supervised do shuffle and deal properly. (Otherwise, you get sharks like me who may be inclined to take advantage).
On April 27, 2008, one of Ondricko's dealers screwed up a shuffle. Before Ondricko realized, cards were in play and 90 seconds had passed. For her mistake, Ondricko was fired. She later sued for race and gender discrimination.
Ondricko asserted that she presented direct evidence of race discrimination based on the VP of Operations' statement: "[D]o you think I wanted to fire Kim, I didn't want to fire Kim, how can I keep the white girl?" Direct evidence is that which would lead a jury to conclude that discrimination at least motivated an employment action.
The Sixth Circuit Court of Appeals (opinion here) agreed:
This statement was made by an MGM decisionmaker shortly before notifying Ondricko of her termination, immediately after discussing inquiries by a fired black female employee's attorney, and in the same meeting where MGM's decision not to fire a black male for similar conduct is discussed. Under these circumstances, and in light of the fact that Boyd [the blank female employee] had a much worse disciplinary record than Ondricko, it is certainly reasonable to conclude from O'Connor's statement that MGM was motivated by a desire to be racially balanced in its terminations for misconduct related to shuffling.
I can imagine that some private employers may be concerned about maintaining a racial balance in the workplace. Forget it! Maintaining racial balance is discrimination. You run a business. Make employment decisions based on qualifications and performance. But you already knew that, right?